Thursday, March 12, 2015

Union and Confederacy Advantages and Disadvantages




The north (Union) and south (Confederacy) both had extremely different advantages regarding agriculture, geography, labor, and population, which all put them at an advantage or disadvantage during the Civil War.  Agriculturally, the north and south differed greatly because of the weather and conditions that certain crops require to grow and thrive; the north possessed far more corn than the south did, but the south possessed all of the cotton in the United States.  This put the north at an advantage food-wise because they could provide more soldiers with more food, considering the versatility of corn and possible uses in many kinds of food.  Basic foods made with corn also would have been cheap to produce in large numbers, so the military could be fed in large numbers for a cheaper cost.  But, the south had the advantage over the north clothing-wise.  The south created all of the cotton in the U.S., and therefore was able to have direct access to it to use for military uniforms, and could  make nicer uniforms because they had the option of making them themselves with their own cotton, rather than having to rely on hand-me-downs or less high quality material.  
The north had far more industrial workers than the south did (1,300,000 versus 110,000), which put them at an advantage and a disadvantage.  Having more industrial workers allowed for the north to be able to have more materials for the war effort like weapons, produced in less time.  But, it also put them at a disadvantage because the more industrial workers they had who had jobs that they loved and spent their whole lives working to perfect the craft that they specialized in, the less people would want to leave their jobs to fight in the war, and risk their lives for a cause that would not change their way of life because slavery was already outlawed in the north.  The south had a far higher number of slaves, 3,500,000 versus 430,000 in the northern border states, which gave them an advantage because the slaves were considered property and could be forced into fighting in the war for the confederacy in a way that the north could not force free industrial workers to fight in the war for the union.  Finally, the north had an advantage over the south in a purely numerical way, considering that the population was far higher in the north (23,000,000 versus 8,700,000), which meant that they simply had more people who were able to fight in the war.
Finally, regarding geography, the north had an advantage or a disadvantage depending on how the situation is perceived.  The north had 22,000 miles of railroad while the south only had 9,000 miles, so the north would have been able to ship more supplies or soldiers across more land faster.  The north also had more factories than the south, 110,100 factories versus 20,600, which meant that they could produce more materials for the military in a shorter amount of time.  But considering the more industrialized nature of the north, the south had far more open land which could have been used to make camp for the confederate army, or could have been used to hide in during war or an attack.
Although the north seemed to have many advantages over the south, southern morale was much higher than that of the north.  Southerners were fighting for their way of life, whereas most northerners lives would not change much whether they won or lost the war.  Seven of the nation's eight military colleges at the time were located in the south and they were intensely training their soldiers, ready to fight for their years-old traditions. 

No comments:

Post a Comment